Hi Paul!
A lot of different things factor into which songs we choose to cover, but number one, the song has to connect to us at some level. Meaning that by playing it we can do more than merely repeat the words and melodies written by someone else.
We always pick something that inspires us and that we get excited about; musically, lyrically, conceptually or all three of those things! 🙂
Sometimes we have a good video idea for a particular song in mind, too. Or it could be that we’re travelling somewhere that has a connection to a particular song we like. Or that we’d like to try something we’ve never done before, songs that intrigue or move us.
We still have a very long list of songs we’d like to give a go one day, and a lot of (to us) influential bands that we’d love to pay homage to by playing one of their tunes. And of course, there are still 300+ more Beatles songs … 300+ more of our favourite songs 😉
“Suite: Judy Blue Eyes” has been on that list for a long time by the way – we love that song. It’s really tempting to have a go at some CSN one day – those harmonies are to die for! If only there were 8, no better 9, 10, 11 days a week 🙂
Thanks for the question!