MonaLisa Twins Homepage › Forums › MLT Club Forum › MLT-FAQs › Close To You
-
Close To You
Posted by Michael Rife on 22/11/2018 at 22:03Hi MLT Team;
Did you ever have second thoughts about the song “Close To You” title? There is another song that came out about 1970 by the same title sorta called “Close To You (They Long to Be)”. But, then that was 48 years ago.  I also know of a other songs that have the same title by different groups, e.g., I Need You by the Beatles (George) and America. BTW the Beatles and the America group have something in common (trivia time).…..but I imagine most on the board know what this is. Anyway just wondering about Close To You……it is a song I really like, too.
Mike
Richard McGlenn replied 5 years, 11 months ago 4 Members · 4 Replies -
4 Replies
-
Hi Mike. Yes it’s a great song. I wouldn’t worry about the title though as there are hundreds of different songs out there with the same title. If the name fits, go with it!
1. ‘The Power of Love’
Three different songs with this title, by Frankie Goes to Hollywood, Huey Lewis and Jennifer Rush, were in the charts in the same year, 1985.
2. ‘Dagenham Dave’
The Stranglers, 1977; Morrissey, 1995.
3. ‘God Is A DJ’
Faithless, 1998; Pink, 2003.
4. ‘Stockholm Syndrome’
Muse and Blink-182 both released albums in 2003 with “Stockholm Syndrome” at track five, and “Interlude” at track seven, notes Lewis James Brown.
5. ‘For Whom the Bell Tolls’
Metallica, 1985; the Bee Gees, 1993.6. ‘God Save the Queen’
The Sex Pistols, 1977, “and the other one”, offers Fiona Laird.
7. ‘Absolute Beginners’
The Jam, 1981; David Bowie, 1986. Nominated by Devil’s Advocate.
8. ‘Come Together’
MC5, February 1969; The Beatles, October 1969; Blur, 1991; Primal Scream, 1991; Spiritualized, 1998. Nominated by Richard.
9. ‘Stairway to Heaven’
Neil Sedaka, 1960; Led Zeppelin, 1971; The O’Jays, 1976 (B-side of “Livin’ for the Weekend”).
10. ‘Who’s that Girl?’
Eurythmics, 1983; Madonna, 1987. With thanks to John Preston.
As for what they had in common with the Beatles I’m not sure. However, their second single release was ‘I Need You’, which was their own song, not the George Harrison song from the ‘Help’ album. George Martin remixed the studio recording for inclusion on History: America’s Greatest Hits (1975)
Their first album America (1971) was recorded at Trident Studios in London. Â Although the trio initially planned to record the album in a similar manner to The Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, Samwell (their producer), convinced them to perfect their acoustic style instead.
-
Hi Mike, that’s not really something we worry about to be honest. It’s actually rather hard to come by song titles that NOONE has ever used before, so we just write our songs, write the lyrics and then name the song, like the song wants to be named 🙂 It’s normally quite self evident due to its lyrics, and we definitely wouldn’t change the lyrics just to get a different title. Hope that makes sense 🙂
-
Yes, it makes perfect sense. I am guessing the song is written first and then the title just naturally happens. I like the song and much of the Orange LP. Hope you and Mona and family are getting ready for a great holiday!!
Mike
-
-
I’ve noticed over the years while thumbing through sheet music books the title of an old song that’s the same as a contemporary song and wondered how they got away with it copyright wise. So I did a little research a few years back and discovered it was a “fuzzy” area when it came to protecting a song title.
Generally, copyright law protection does not extend to song titles because they usually are short and lack sufficient originality. Therefore, you can (and often do) have multiple songs with the same name, and the first to name their song, for example “Crazy,” does not have the right to stop other people from releasing their own songs named “Crazy.” An exception to this is that some long titles may be found to have sufficient originality to be afforded copyright protection.
If the song was a hit song, the song title could be protected from unfair competition as a trademark under trademark law. A trademark is a word, phrase or symbol that is used to identify and distinguish the source of a product or service. You might think of it like a brand.
And this is why there are copyright lawyers.
The forum ‘MLT-FAQs’ is closed to new discussions and replies.